Zitationsvorschlag

Luckmann, Alexander: Hermann Muthesius als Denkmalpfleger? Szenarien möglicher Zukünfte der Denkmalpflege, in Blokker, Johanna und Hönig, Svenja (Hrsg.): Erhalten und Gestalten: Zum Verhältnis zwischen Denkmalpflege und Architektur, Heidelberg: arthistoricum.net, 2026 (Veröffentlichungen des Arbeitskreises Theorie und Lehre der Denkmalpflege e.V., Band 35), S. 20–27. https://doi.org/10.11588/arthistoricum.1814.c27824

Identifier (Buch)

ISBN 978-3-98501-460-6 (PDF)

Veröffentlicht

05.08.2026

Autor/innen

Alexander Luckmann

Hermann Muthesius als Denkmalpfleger?

Szenarien möglicher Zukünfte der Denkmalpflege

While Hermann Muthesius has been the subject of extensive scholarly attention since the opening of his archive in 1995, his contributions to historic preservation remain understudied. This essay analyzes a series of writings on preservation that Hermann Muthesius published between 1897 and 1904. It identifies four main aspects of his stance and approach: first, his attachment to English models of preservation practice and specifically those of the Society for the Protection of Ancient Buildings (SPAB), which Muthesius aimed to introduce to a German audience; second, his belief in the important role to be played by “the public“ in historic preservation; third, his understanding of heritage buildings as historical documents that ought to be read, understood, and valued as such; and fourth, his argument that an appropriate preservation practice must be part of the renaissance of architecture and art for which he and others were striving, and therefore part of a “modern art movement“. These ideas were first expressed in his 1897 article “The Cathedral of Peterborough and Historic Preservation in England“, and were most fully developed in “The ‘Restoration’ of Our Old Buildings“ of 1902/1904.
This paper places Muthesius‘ preservation thinking both within his larger architectural and literary oeuvre and within preservation discourses at the turn of the 20th century. It concludes by questioning why Muthesius did not return to the topic of conservation after 1904, even though the destruction of World War I made the repair and reconstruction of damaged heritage a key topic of cultural debate.